Three listings that are not what the directories say
Flinchbaugh’s Orchard and Farm Market, 110 Ducktown Road, Hellam ·
717-252-2540. Listed as a York County Christmas tree farm. Their own Christmas page offers a
Christmas market, holiday bakery orders and “Christmas decor — bows, greens,
arrangements”, and does not mention trees anywhere. Go for the wreaths and the
baking, not to cut a tree.
Mad Radish Farm, 1991 George Street, Dover · 443-643-5684. The directories list
it as “formerly 3 Gs Trees Cut Your Own Tree Farm”, and that “formerly”
appears to be the whole story: the current farm’s site covers a farm stand and
pick-your-own and says nothing about Christmas trees at all. Ring before you count on it.
Strathmeyer Christmas Trees, 334 Carlisle Avenue, York · 717-292-5683. A large
grower with a lot at the York Expo Center rather than a field you walk. Their site is dated 2020
and disagrees with itself about whether the firm started in 1932 or 1936. Fine for a pre-cut
tree; not a choose-and-cut.
York County Christmas tree questions
Where can you cut your own Christmas tree in York County, PA?
9 farms publish enough to plan around. Brown’s just outside York is the best known and sells any field tree for $84; McCurdy’s in Dillsburg names eight varieties and has a wagon ride and Santa; Cornerstone in Glen Rock grows seven species; Haring in Goldsboro names five; McPherson in Hallam is tagging again; Elicker’s in Dillsburg is a small cut-your-own; Family Tree Farm in Red Lion opens weekdays only from 1 December; Lloyd’s in Fawn Grove opens for two weekends, at $50 for any tree last year; and Old Forge in Brogue has a church-run Christmas shop.
When do York County Christmas tree farms open in 2026?
Brown’s opens first, on Saturday 21 November: its rule is “Opening Day Saturday before Thanksgiving”. McCurdy’s opens on Friday 27 November 2026 at 9am, and Cornerstone the same day. Haring’s site still reads “November 22, 2025”, Elicker’s, McPherson, Lloyd’s and Old Forge have not posted dates, and Family Tree Farm starts on Tuesday 1 December, weekdays only, 1pm to 5pm. Ring before you go.
How much is a Christmas tree in York County?
Brown’s charges $84 plus Pennsylvania sales tax for any field tree, any size, so a 12 ft tree costs the same as a 5 ft one. Cornerstone’s latest list, from 2024, is $70 for a Fraser fir and $60 for anything else, Haring sells pre-cut trees from $79, no year given, and Lloyd’s charged $50 for any tree in 2025. For comparison, Hunt’s in Lancaster runs $100 to $130 at 6–8 ft, and our what a tree costs page collects every real list we hold.
Which York County farm is best with children?
McCurdy’s in Dillsburg, comfortably. A tractor-wagon ride out to the trees, farm animals, Santa, music and weekend entertainment, a food trailer, and no admission fee — you pay for the tree and nothing else. In tree season it is open Monday to Saturday 9am to 6pm and Sunday 9am to 5pm, and it closes at 2pm on Christmas Eve. Outside the season the farm keeps shorter hours and shuts on Sundays, and the wagon stops boarding well before closing, so go earlier in the day than you think you need to.
Is York County or Lancaster County better for cutting your own tree?
Lancaster, on the evidence. It has more farms, nearly all with a 2026 opening date, a full published price list at Hunt’s and free tagging from 1 October. York has four dated farms of nine. What York has is cheap flat prices: Brown’s $84 for any field tree, and Cornerstone’s $60 to $70 on its 2024 list, and Lloyd’s $50 last year. The two counties are about an hour apart, so you can reasonably choose on that basis.
Can I bring my dog?
At McCurdy’s, on a lead — its rule is “No unleashed pets”. None of the others say either way. Ring first if it matters, because a wasted drive with a dog in the car is worse than the phone call.
Why does this page have fewer farms than the Lancaster one?
Because fewer York farms publish anything we can stand behind. Several in the directories have stopped selling trees, gone quiet for years or let their websites lapse, and some are lots or markets rather than fields you walk. We list the nine we can describe and leave the rest off.
How these were checked
Every listing above was read on the farm’s own website or Facebook page, and each card carries the date it was last read. Four of the seven have a 2026 opening date; Brown’s gives it as a standing rule and Family Tree Farm with no year attached, and the cards say so. For the other three the opening column is left empty rather than carrying last season forward.
Three farms the directories list as choose-and-cut are not, as far as their own sites show,
and they are named above with what they actually are. Dates and prices change: ring the farm
before you set off, and if something here has gone stale, say so and it gets fixed.